How To Generate Small Business Insurance Leads

It’s no secret that lead generation isn’t the same for smaller insurance companies. Not only must these companies be much craftier in acquiring small business insurance leads, but they must also ensure a perfect customer journey for every potential client – just as good as their renowned competitors would offer.

At the same time, investing in lead generation is still paramount. According to LeadSquared, companies that invest over 15% of revenue in generating leads for small business insurance are more likely to experience significant growth. For small businesses, though, this 15% is much less in real numbers.

So, how do you fill your pipeline with small business insurance leads for agents?

How To Generate Small Business Insurance Leads

Source: GIPHY

The answer is below. Read on to learn about how to generate small business insurance leads and turn them into paying customers.

First Things First: Identify Your Target Business Insurance Leads

Even though some lead generation strategies might overlap for all types of small business insurance leads, you must define your ideal buyer in the first place. For example, if your focus is commercial insurance business leads, you might want to double down on B2B lead generation strategies and have to deal with a longer and more complex sales cycle. The same applies to other different types of leads.

Long story short, you must know who your insurance business leads – demographics, psychographics, history of purchases, etc. – and what your unique selling points are in the context of their major interests, motivations, and pain points.

At the same time, as long as you’re selling business coverage in the B2B insurance market, it would help to know what insurance policies are popular with the small businesses that fall into your target audience:

Young Businesses Young companies often require basic coverage like general liability and property insurance. As an insurer, you nurture aspiring businesses by giving advice on navigating the primary insurance challenges and offering a special insurance package that reflects the popular needs of a starting business.
Established Businesses Developed companies usually have more complex needs like workers’ compensation, cyber liability, or business interruption insurance. Commercial insurance prospecting for such businesses must include risk management strategies and coverage for larger workforces.

Likewise, different industries have different risk profiles. For example, a construction company that faces workplace hazards likely needs general liability and workers’ compensation coverage. Conversely, a bakery may prioritize property insurance to protect against fire and food spoilage.

Last but not least, small businesses are known to save money. In other words, most of them are interested in how your specific insurance policy will help them save money while providing great risk mitigation (and making employees happy if we’re talking about workers’ compensation and other employee benefits).

Happy female employee is checking her phone at work

With all that in mind, a good option would be to develop flexible coverage plans for B2B insurance leads and let them customize their policy if needed. It’s only natural that companies select the type and amount of coverage based on their values, needs, risk tolerance, workforce, and multiple other factors.

How To Get Small Business Insurance Leads

Whether auto, health, or other business insurance avenue, generating leads in bulk can be challenging if you have limited resources. Fortunately, there are some effective tactics and channels to help you build a steady stream of leads.

Content Marketing

Not only should your content marketing efforts focus on the needs and wants of your leads, but they should vividly illustrate your unique selling points and be SEO-optimized to hit the top of SERPs.

Here are a few content marketing suggestions you might want to consider:

  • Informative blog posts (for example, risk management education)
  • Guest posts on relevant sites
  • Free webinars
  • Infographics, quizzes, and other interactive content
  • Interviews, case studies, success stories, etc.

SEO-wise, your content should be optimized to answer a particular search intent. Tools like Ahrefs can help you discover the most popular search queries to use as a core part of your content marketing strategy.

Two female marketers are creating great content for generating small business insurance leads

For example, this very article uses the “small business insurance leads” keyword as the underlying search query while covering its search intent: reveal working lead gen strategies to acquire as many high-intent B2B insurance leads as possible.

Website Optimization

Your website is your virtual storefront, a focal point of your lead generation strategy. Therefore, make sure it is clear, user-friendly, and effectively communicates the value of your small business insurance solutions.

Here are some basic website optimization advice:

  • Use clear and concise titles and descriptions
  • Highlight the benefits of your insurance coverage
  • Include testimonials from satisfied customers
  • Make the application process simple and convenient

To increase conversions, strategically place lead capture forms on your website. Offer valuable incentives like free consultations, downloadable resources, or insurance quotes in exchange for contact information. This will encourage visitors to interact and be a gateway to further communication and relationship building.

Social Media Marketing

Small business owners are constantly online, particularly on LinkedIn and Twitter, so it makes sense to make full use of social media:

Become a Thought Leader Share informative content relevant to small businesses, such as articles discussing risk management strategies or specific insurance needs.
Participate in Industry Discussions Participate in discussions in groups and by relevant hashtags. Offer ideas and answer questions to establish yourself as a knowledgeable expert.
Contact Potential Customers in Private Messages Actively engage with small business owners and decision-makers on social media.

Also, consider the power of targeted advertising. Social media platforms allow you to reach very specific audiences based on demographics, industry, and interests. This ensures that your message reaches the ideal prospects who are most likely to need your small business insurance solutions.

Lead Generation Challenges When Selling Small Business Insurance

High Competition The small business insurance industry is saturated, with many agents and brokers vying for the same leads, making it difficult to stand out.
Segmentation If you haven’t clearly defined your target audience, all your efforts may be in vain. Understanding the needs and challenges of small business owners in your niche is essential to reach them effectively.
Suboptimal Marketing Strategies If you don’t use effective marketing strategies to attract potential customers, you won’t be able to reach your lead generation goals. You need an omnichannel marketing plan that includes your website, social media, content marketing, and direct marketing.
Lack of Qualification You need qualified staff who can efficiently generate insurance leads and qualify them. If you don’t have the resources you require, you will struggle to achieve your lead generation goals.
Inefficient Sales Process Even if you succeed in generating leads, you’ll still need an effective sales process to convert them into customers. Your sales process should be clearly defined and focused on potential customers’ needs.

Small Business Insurance Lead Nurturing: Driving Leads To a Conversion

Acquiring qualified leads is only the first step – you also need to nurture them so they eventually convert, bringing you profits that you can reinvest into refining your lead generation strategies.

A company's client is shooting the unpacking of the product

Here’s why lead nurturing is crucial when it comes to business leads:

  • Complex decision-making. Small businesses often need time to research and compare options before making a decision. Constant communication and valuable content will keep you on their radar.
  • Demand for trust. Nurturing prospects helps you build trust and establish yourself as a trusted advisor, making them more likely to choose you when the time comes.

By nurturing leads you’ve attracted through valuable content or targeted marketing efforts, you’re developing genuine relationships and demonstrating your expertise. This might be your best investment in long-term relationships with clients.

How To Get Business Insurance Leads Instantly

Organic B2B lead generation requires a multifaceted approach – content marketing SMM, SEO, networking, etc – but what if you need business insurance leads here and now to get the ball rolling with sales?

For quick small business insurance lead acquisition, Profitise is the answer. 

Profitise unites hundreds of small business owners and quality publishers so everyone gets what they need: pre-qualified leads, including B2B leads, or due remuneration for the generated leads.

Once you’ve signed up, you get a wide selection of leads from trusted sources, competitive pricing, a safe and secure platform for buying and selling, and a professional support team to help at any time.

To kick things off with Profitise, register as an affiliate or advertiser. For questions, contact us at or call 888-400-4868.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can insurance providers identify their target small businesses?

Insurance providers identify small businesses that require coverage by analyzing the niche in general and creating an ideal buyer profile for their insurance products.

What strategies can insurance providers use to stand out?

Insurers must create a unique selling proposition that reflects their clients’ needs and wants. For example, if you are selling business van insurance, you might want to analyze what business van insurance leads want that they don’t get in your target market and then try to fill this gap with your insurance product.

How long does it take to convert a small business insurance lead into a policyholder?

The conversion process usually takes several weeks or months, depending on the niche, the decision-making process, how urgent it is for the lead to get an insurance policy, and other nuances.


Get articles delivered directly to your inbox.